No. 07-2165 (2/11/08). Appeal, E.D. Wisc. Rev’d and rem’d.
Dist. Ct. erred in confirming arbitration award in favor of defendant-insurance company where plaintiff-insured sought declaration that defendant’s unilateral raising of deductible in "stop loss" health insurance policy based on plaintiff’s failure to inform defendant of serious medical condition of one of policy’s participants was contrary to Wisc. law. Under Wisc. law, raising of deductible would not be appropriate if plaintiff neither knew nor had reason to know at time of its representation to defendant that no plan participant was likely to have serous medical condition, and arbitrator, pursuant to instruction to "strictly" follow Wisc. law, should have determined whether plaintiff had such knowledge prior to rendering decision in arbitration.